---
title: "Ask for a second review of a refused message"
description: "An independent reviewer re-judges the same content under the same policy. Four possible outcomes, all of them honest."
url: https://help.mails.ai/en/articles/17-ask-for-a-second-review-of-a-refused-message
collection: "Deliverability and policy"
updated: 2026-10-10
language: en
---

# Ask for a second review of a refused message

An independent reviewer re-judges the same content under the same policy. Four possible outcomes, all of them honest.

![Mails.ai — Ask for a second review of a refused message](https://staticfiles.gleap.io/p6a77ce6bbe980ea9dbca1955/0VuLHoCWiob1FB1vItR2g7WqVXfK2eth7BeGdBs2w4f1KK8zD57g2jbqyu7DGenXAZ6caqB1fKi.png)

Press **Ask for a second review** in the composer — it appears beside a cold-mail refusal from **Send now** or **Send test** — or call `POST /v1/messages/appeal` with the same subject and body the refused send used. A second, independent judgment is made under the identical policy — a review is not a softer pass, it is a different reader.

![A refused test send in the composer, with the Ask for a second review button beside the verdict](https://staticfiles.gleap.io/p6a77ce6bbe980ea9dbca1955/kK4mc6BWMmJEo3wIGQIOVXqBGAlfAnDZy1LG7L6SHVso8qX7xDGjrrSh99YTApnM4ZJ7Mw8sDFH.png)

## The four outcomes

-   `overturned` — that exact content is cleared for 24 hours and the identical send goes through.
    
-   `upheld` — the refusal stands. The content is cold outreach or marketing under the same policy a second reader applied.
    
-   `not_appealable` — the block is deterministic policy (prohibited content, bulk-list language, a multi-signal cold pitch). There is no review to run, and saying so beats pretending to review it.
    
-   `not_blocked` — the content is not refused at all; something else went wrong with your send.
    

## Two things worth knowing

-   **An appeal is not a re-roll.** For 24 hours, identical content replays its stored outcome, so re-submitting the same message changes nothing.
    
-   **Ten appeals per workspace per 24 hours.**
    

If a whole class of your legitimate mail is being refused, that is a product problem on our side and worth an email — the appeal path is for individual messages, not for a systematic mismatch.

[Email support@mails.ai](mailto:support@mails.ai)
