Why a send came back cold_email_prohibited

What triggers the verdict, what a passing message looks like, and how to check a message without sending it.

Mails.ai — Why a send came back cold_email_prohibited

422 cold_email_prohibited means the outbound firewall refused the message: most often as cold outreach or bulk marketing, but the same code also covers spam, prohibited content and phishing-style links, and the message on the refusal says which. Mails.ai carries transactional, recipient-initiated mail only, and this refusal is the mechanism, not an accident.

The composer after Send test on a sales pitch: nothing was sent, a live send would be refused as cold outreach, and the Ask for a second review button

What triggers it

That verdict fires when a message pitches a product or service to someone who did not ask for it, or reads as bulk or marketing mail. A first message to someone who has never written to you is judged more strictly, but it is not refused for that alone.

What passes

Mail that passes is a reply to a message the recipient sent you, or a confirmation, receipt, notification, reminder or verification addressed to someone who just took an action.

Check a message without sending it

Send it with a test key (mk_test_...), or press Send test in the dashboard composer. Test sends are classified and the verdict is returned to you, but nothing is transmitted and nothing is billed. That turns a refusal into a ten-second edit instead of a support thread.

If you think the verdict is wrong, there is a real appeal — see the next article. "Contact support" is not the answer we want to give you, and it is no longer the answer the API gives.

Open the composer
Did this answer your question?
😞
😐
😁